Your milk check pays for components. Right now, the components do not pay the same. Butter hit its lowest monthly average of 2026 in September, while milk solids kept climbing. That gap changes how a nutritionist should price every pound of added fat.
Here are the September numbers, what research says a palmitic acid supplement can and cannot do, and a simple way to test whether a fat supplement pays on your farm.
What the September Numbers Say
USDA’s Dairy Monthly Averages report from October 9 shows a split market. CME butter averaged $1.3746 per pound in September. That is the lowest monthly average of 2026 and about 27 percent below March’s $1.8885.
Cream followed. Northeast Class II cream averaged $1.9510 per pound of butterfat in September, down about 21 percent from $2.4715 in March.
Solids went the other way. CME Grade A nonfat dry milk averaged $2.0356 per pound, up about 18 percent from August. Dry whey averaged $0.7740, its 2026 high. Whey protein concentrate 34 percent averaged about $2.51 in the Central and West regions, up from about $1.50 in January.
Fluid milk moved up too. USDA set the October base Class I price at $18.88 per hundredweight, $1.84 above September, according to USDA Dairy Market News.
Keep the limits in mind. These are market averages, not your milk check. Your price depends on your order, your buyer, and your components.
What a Palmitic Acid Supplement Did in Research
Palmitic acid is a long-chain fatty acid found in milk fat. Researchers have tested concentrated palmitic acid supplements in lactating cows. Two studies show the pattern.
In a trial reported in the Journal of Dairy Science, 24 Holstein cows received a supplement with 85 percent palmitic acid. The authors report milk fat content of 4.25 percent versus 3.99 percent for the control. Milk fat yield was 1.48 versus 1.39 kilograms per day, and feed efficiency was 1.51 versus 1.42. Dry matter intake, body weight, body condition score, and yields of milk, protein, and lactose did not change. The abstract is available at AGRIS.
A second study used 39 Holstein cows. A high palmitic supplement raised milk fat content by 8.6 percent and milk fat yield by 16.2 percent compared with no supplement. It had no effect on milk production or on milk protein and lactose. The paper appears in Tropical and Subtropical Agroecosystems.
Both studies point the same way. Palmitic acid moved fat. It did not move protein or milk volume. Results vary by herd, diet, and stage of lactation, so treat these as a guide, not a promise.
Why Butterfat Fell While Solids Rose
The same USDA report shows why. Global powder prices climbed in September. Oceania skim milk powder averaged $3,664 per metric ton, about 10 percent above August. West Europe skim milk powder averaged $3,653, about 7 percent higher.
Butter went the other way. Oceania butter averaged $4,948 per metric ton, its lowest of the year. West Europe butter held nearly flat at $4,661.
Buyers around the world wanted powders more than butter. That pushed solids up and left butterfat behind. Markets can turn quickly, so do not build a ration plan on one month of prices. Use the numbers to ask better questions.
Do the Math on Your Own Check
When butterfat pays less, each added pound of fat earns less. That does not make a supplement a bad buy. It means you should check the return.
- Find the butterfat price on your own milk check.
- Ask your nutritionist how many added pounds of fat per cow per day to expect.
- Multiply the two numbers.
- Compare the result with the supplement’s cost per cow per day.
Here is an example. The first trial above showed 0.09 kilograms more fat per day, about 0.2 pounds. At a butterfat price of $1.50 per pound, that gain is worth $0.30 per cow per day. If the supplement costs more than that to feed, it does not pay on fat alone. The $1.50 figure is only an example, so use your own price.
Count other benefits separately. Energy density, body condition, and herd health matter. List each as its own line, and decide with your nutritionist what each is worth.
Three Butterfat Prices, One Supplement
Prices change, so test your plan against more than one number. Take the same gain of 0.2 pounds of fat per cow per day. These values are examples only.
- At $1.25 per pound of butterfat, the gain is worth $0.25 per cow per day.
- At $1.50 per pound, the gain is worth $0.30.
- At $1.75 per pound, the gain is worth $0.35.
The spread is ten cents per cow per day. On a herd of 1,000 milking cows, that is $100 per day. A supplement that pays at one price may not pay at another.
Use this to set a limit. Decide what supplement cost per cow per day you can accept at the low end of the range. Then check whether you can hold that cost if palm oil moves.

Read the Fatty Acid Profile in the Spec
Fat supplements carry different fatty acids. The spec shows what you are buying.
FoodGrid’s CAL+ spec packet lists calcium salts of long-chain fatty acids made from palm oil. It sets palmitic acid at 44 to 52 percent and oleic acid at 33 to 39 percent. Linoleic acid runs 7 to 11 percent, and stearic acid runs 3 to 7 percent. Fat is 82.5 percent minimum, calcium is 8 to 11 percent, and moisture is 5 percent maximum. Shelf life is 15 months when stored below 110 degrees Fahrenheit in the original packaging.
The P85+ spec packet describes a palm oil fatty acid. It sets C16 at 85 percent minimum and fat at 99 percent. It lists a white bead appearance, an iodine value below 0.5, and a melt point above 56 degrees Celsius. Shelf life is 12 months when stored below 110 degrees Fahrenheit in the original packaging.
P85+ is concentrated palmitic acid. CAL+ carries a broader mix. Each profile suits a different feeding plan, and your nutritionist decides which one fits your herd.
FoodGrid describes CAL+ as a reacted rumen bypass fat that works without interfering with rumen microbial activity. FoodGrid also reports that P85+ has been shown to increase butterfat production in dairy cows. Treat those as company claims. Ask for the technical data sheet and a certificate of analysis, and judge them against your own herd data.
Storage and Handling: Protect the Spec
A spec helps only if the product on your floor still matches it. Both packets call for storage below 110 degrees Fahrenheit in the original packaging, and both warn that poor storage can raise the risk of oxidation.
Moisture matters too. The CAL+ packet caps moisture at 5 percent, and wet product can clump in automated feeding systems. Keep bags and totes dry, off the floor, and away from heat.
Rotate stock. Use the oldest lots first and track shelf life: 15 months for CAL+ and 12 months for P85+. Ask your supplier to print the production date on every lot.
Check each delivery. Look at the packaging, the lot number, and the certificate of analysis. Record any problem the same day.
Do Not Forget the Solids
Milk protein and other solids pay more this fall. The studies above showed no protein response from palmitic acid. If protein pays well on your check, ask your nutritionist what supports protein yield in your ration. Total energy supply, intake, and amino acid balance are good places to start.
A fat plan and a protein plan can work together. A fat plan alone may miss half the check.
Watch the Raw Material Too
CAL+ and P85+ both start with palm raw materials, which ties feed fat costs to the palm oil market.
PalmPulse, published by the Malaysian Palm Oil Council, reports that crude palm oil traded between RM4,600 and RM5,050 per tonne in September. It forecasts prices above RM4,600 in October, with El Niño dry weather and strong energy prices as the main drivers. These are forecasts, and they can change.
Ask your supplier how long a quote stays valid before you lock in your Q1 winter ration volume.
If Your Milk Fat Is Already Low
A supplement is not the first fix for every low fat test. Low milk fat has many causes. Rumen health, fiber intake, and the amount of unsaturated fat in the diet all play a part. A fat supplement will not repair a problem that starts in the rumen.
Before you add anything, ask your nutritionist to review the basics. Look at forage quality, particle size, and feeding consistency. Check whether cows are sorting the ration. Then decide whether added fat fits the plan.
Fix the cause first. Then add a supplement if the math still works.
Questions to Bring to Your Nutritionist
- What milk fat and protein tests are we aiming for this winter?
- Which fat sources are in the ration today, and at what level?
- What gain in fat yield do we expect from a new supplement, and how will we measure it?
- What happens to the plan if butterfat prices fall again?
- What would we need to see to stop the supplement?
Write the answers down. A written plan makes it easier to judge results in January.
A Winter Ration Review Checklist
- Pull your last three milk checks and note what fat and protein paid.
- Ask your nutritionist to model your current ration against two or three options.
- Request a technical data sheet and a certificate of analysis for each fat supplement.
- Check storage space, moisture, and flow in your mixing system before the first delivery.
- Ask suppliers for price validity windows and lead times.
- Set one owner and one date for each task.
What to Ask Any Fat Supplement Supplier
Whether you buy direct or through a distributor, ask the same questions.
- What is the fatty acid profile, and how does it vary from lot to lot?
- What are the moisture and fat limits on the spec?
- How does the product flow and mix in an automated feeding system?
- What is your lead time, and how does it change in winter?
- What documents ship with each lot?
- Can you support technical questions before we commit?
Give more weight to suppliers who answer in writing.
Keep Records for Next Season
Good decisions come from your own data. Start a simple log now and keep it through spring.
- Record milk fat and protein tests each month.
- Record the supplement, the feeding level, and the cost per cow per day.
- Note changes in forage, weather, and management.
- Write down the milk prices you received for fat and protein.
In April, compare the log with your plan. You will see what paid and what did not, and you can set next winter’s ration from facts.
Review the Ration Before Winter
A split market rewards teams that check the math. Butterfat is cheap, solids are strong, and winter is close. A short review now costs little. A drop in milk components shows up weeks later on a test report, after the chance to adjust has passed.
Market prices move daily. Check live figures from USDA and your own milk check before you decide.
Request a Sample Today
FoodGrid supplies CAL+ calcium salt and P85+ palmitic acid with full documentation. Request a sample or contact our animal nutrition team to plan your winter ration supply.
Real Ingredients. Smarter Solutions.
